How nice do I really have to be?

Download a printable copy of this article (PDF 527KB)

How nice do I really have to be?

  • Look to balance firmness and fairness at all times.
  • The 3:1 Rule has merit.
  • The best relationships include constructive feedback experiences.
  • Teachers CAN smile before Easter.
  • A focus on the positive without ignoring an area for improvement is key.

I firmly remember many things from my first year or two of teaching. Some are a lot fuzzier. But a memory I have from very early on was being told by one experienced staff member not to be too nice. “Huh?” I muttered, thinking that this wasn’t mentioned in my four years at university. “You know” he went on, “don’t let them walk all over you.”

A lot of do-gooders will tell you that you have to be nice to the kids and allow them to express themselves. Well, I’m here to tell you that the only thing you have to do is show them who’s in charge. That’s Teaching 101 as far as I’m concerned.” It is likely you’ve heard advice along those lines and many of us have heard and grappled with the well-worn phrase, “don’t smile before Easter.”

Welcome to teaching!

I remember the fog of confusion I was in as I walked to my classroom. I had been ready to be very nice and super positive. I was about to walk in as educational Pollyanna and create my own little classroom of happiness. Yet, here was an experienced practitioner telling me this was bad policy. Was I right? Was he right? Or was there a way that we both might have a point?

“It is important to stay positive, because beauty comes from the inside out.”
– Jenn Proske

The short story is that I survived that year mostly by being a nice guy. I was occasionally bad tempered and occasionally chose the wrong practices and strategies. Show me a graduate teacher who hasn’t! It was a fabulous year of learning and I hope it was for my students too.

What I later discovered was that I was right to look for a hybrid model; that a balance of firm and fair in my practice was a desirable endeavour and that my reflection would best be geared towards the most effective balance quotient. Enter Marcial Losada.

Losada, with the assistance of renowned psychologist Barbara Fredrickson, looked hard at the way human beings interact. He looked at the positive interactions and their impact – and he looked at the negative. He also counted them and compared the ratios of positive to negative interactions against the perceived and actual function or dysfunction of the relationships within which they occurred. What Losada came up with was the right ratio … or the balance between firm and fair that I’d been looking for.

It turns out that one negative interaction to every 2.9013 positive interactions can take a relationship out of a languishing state and into a flourishing state. As with most statistically valid research the real challenge is what to do with it.

So let’s consider the Losada Ratio more practically, on a bell curve where we round the desired ratio to 3 to 1.

It seems that when it comes to the question of how nice we need to be to make our classrooms work, we have found the answer! The contextualising of Losada’s work in your classroom might be the critical factor in effectively leveraging functional relationships for better student performance.

Where a ratio of around three positives per negative is achieved the relationship is the most functional. It’s conducive to learning, safety and can be leveraged by the teacher for improved student performance.

Losada's ratio on a bell curve

 

Where there is around one negative for every positive, the relationship is in dysfunction. The student will feel you are picking on them incessantly.

Where there is around one negative for every six positive, the relationship is also in dysfunction. The student feels no challenge to improve! This is irritating and undesirable.

References

Barbara Frederickson explains “The Positivity Ratio”
Bibliography: YouTube. (2019). Barbara Fredrickson: The Positivity Ratio. [online]
Available at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_hFzxfQpLjM

Further reading

More articles in the Counter-bullying responses topic

A fairer process

There is no fair outcome without a fair process. It’s the process, the rules, the patterns by which we get things done together that will ultimately determine our views of how fair things really are.

Read more

This is your captain speaking

Your voice is one of your most potent tools in the classroom. Cultivate it, experiment with it, develop it, create with it and make it something that is a contextual feature of your high expectation environment.

Read more

Why parents and carers listen to shock jocks

The cult of expertise flooding the national schools conversation concerns me. These days it seems anybody who has walked past a school in the last three or four decades is fully qualified to comment on your decisions, your craft, your technical skill and your capacity for the task of educating.

Read more

Why students lie

I look back with a wry smile at some of the odd things I’ve said to students as a teacher. Once I told my class that if they were all going to have a rubbish attitude that I’d be making each of them stand in the dumpster at recess. Clearly a ridiculous threat that would never be carried out, and all of us were falling about with laughter for a moment while I came back to my senses.

Read more

The woeful word why

We all like to know why we need to do things, far more than we like to know what we need to do or how we are expected to do it. Human motivation is largely driven by a clear purpose. Many of us chose teaching as a profession because we wanted to make a big difference in the lives of students, a why, and not because of the occasional opportunity to show students how to conjugate verbs, that’s a how or what.

Read more

That’s not fair!

I remember teaching a fabulous class of Year 6 students who had a special sense of humour. They were also characterised by a wonderful camaraderie which made hearing about their regular escapades on weekends or even during lunch breaks a real joy. There was little ego, but a pervading inclusivity that has made me remember them fondly despite the passage of fifteen years since teaching them.

Read more

Respect in our schools

We have to be more determined about giving respect before we get it.

Read more

Beating bullying… bit by bit

The literature around bullying tells us that it’s far less a behavioural issue than a cultural one. That is, when students who have been engaging in bullying behaviours or students who have been bullied move from a school where bullying is normalised, into a school where it is not, they will experience a significant reduction in either bullying behaviours or being bullied.

Read more

Teaching and defining empathy

Given the thousands of anti-bullying programs that have been developed around the world, it’s little wonder that teachers have grown tired of implementing them for little return. It is clear that bullying isn’t beaten with a program, but through teaching, fostering and valuing empathy. Put simply, empathic young people don’t inflict power-driven negative and destructive behaviours upon others.

Read more